To Loot, or Not To Loot (That is the Controversy)

Luis Scott-Vargas posed an interesting question revolving around a particular card:


Check out the original question here.

The article launched a firestorm in the Twittersphere, with pros, grinders, and casual players debating the question. To some people, you loot, and it’s not even close, others say it’s a little more nuanced than that. LSV posted a follow up article here (spoiler: he argues you loot).

However, Brian Braun-Duin disagreed, and posted why you don’t loot, here.

What would you do?